Tiffany's Coffee & Specialty Donuts: A Cozy Haven for Donut Lovers and Coffee Enthusiasts

Top categories (Refreshers / Coffee / Other Sips)
Most orders: $1–10

If you find yourself wandering the charming streets of Matamoras, Pennsylvania, a delightful destination awaits at Tiffany's Coffee & Specialty Donuts. Nestled at 1004 Pennsylvania Ave, this quaint coffee shop is not just a pit stop for caffeine enthusiasts; it's a sanctuary for anyone who appreciates the art of coffee and the indulgence of tempting donuts.

Stepping into Tiffany's feels like entering a warm embrace. The ambiance is cozy, inviting customers to relax and unwind. It's no wonder that patrons quickly find their favorite nook to sip, savor, and socialize. As customer Shane Fogarty noted, the donuts are truly “awesome,” making it a perfect spot to sample a variety of their delightful treats. And with small donut sizes, you can guiltlessly indulge in multiple flavors!

The menu is a treasure trove for coffee lovers. From expertly crafted iced coffees to luxurious hot lattes, the range is impressive. Patrons rave about the iced chai lattes and iced black coffee, with many declaring them among the best they’ve ever tasted. Far from an ordinary coffee shop, Tiffany's offers a plethora of tantalizing refresher drinks, each priced at US$4.95. Flavors like Strawberry Acai and Dragon Fruit Lychee are sure to invigorate your senses.

While the coffee and refresher selections shine, it's hard to ignore the stars of the show - the donuts. Each bite reveals a world of flavor, leaving customers like JW SeChrist astounded by the variety and quality. With each dozen purchased, you embark on a flavorful adventure that will keep you coming back for more. Whether you are grabbing a quick treat or planning to share with friends, the donuts at Tiffany's are a must-try.

Furthermore, the attentive staff, who are always ready to offer recommendations, enhance the overall experience. Customer A T highlighted the patience and kindness of the employees, making first-time visitors feel right at home. This personal touch is what a community coffee shop is all about – a space that fosters connections over delicious food and drinks.

At Tiffany's Coffee & Specialty Donuts, every sip and every bite is a testament to the love poured into their craft. If you're in the area, be sure to indulge in the comforting atmosphere, explore the extensive drink menu, and savor those delectable donuts. Your taste buds will thank you!

Contact them at: +1 570-491-8181 for inquiries or visit their social media to catch the weekly specials!

Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery

Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible car park

Credit cards

Shane Fogarty

06/10/2025

Awesome doughnuts and great place to relax. Mini so try a few different ones.

Irasema Perez

02/10/2025

Their donuts are delicious and the capuchino is excellent as well! I love small business who put love on their work.

A T

20/09/2025

Each employee smiled and greeted me with a warm welcome upon entering for my first time. This place is so comfortable and cute! I really liked the retail section and the lounge area on the other side, it felt like a place I could chill out for a bit with my coffee. My friend and I took forever to order but the young lady at the register was so patient with us. She also helped us with suggestions which was really kind and very helpful as we were so indecisive with such a wide selection to try! I unfortunately didn’t love my coffee but I’ll go back to try something different. I’d like to try some of the donuts next time as well!

JW SeChrist

25/08/2025

I had heard of Tiffany’s and I decided to stop there on the way back through Ma I had heard of Tiffany’s and I decided to stop there on the way back through Madam Matamoras. I got a dozen donuts and an iced black coffee. The iced black coffee was profession and had no bad aftertaste that some coffees have. It actually tasted really good. I did not know what to expect with the donuts because they’re very small but I have to say the variety and the tastes very impressive. I took the dozen donuts to my father’s house in Milford and let him have a couple and he enjoyed them. I hammered the remaining ones quickly. I liked them all, and there was not one bad flavor in the dozen. I’ll be stopping there next time. I’m on the Rio reservoir.

Tony Marinaro

18/08/2025

Today was our first time here and we will absolutely be back! We got hot chai lattes and I have to say it was the best I've ever had or at least since Port Java was around. The atmosphere was warm, inviting and much appreciated on such a cold day. Thank you.

Abbie Bateman

08/08/2025

Just about the cutest coffee shop I’ve ever been to. In such a beautiful little town. Just stopped while I was passing through and grabbed a coffee (delicious). Also… I think Cory should let Tiffany get the hot display case she wants for the sandwiches because I’d have gotten one Highly recommend!

Avery Larson

30/06/2025

Was out for the grand opening, there was a fairly long line but the wait was not bad. I got chai latte and my partner got a regular latte, we both love the coffee from black and brass so this really hit the spot! We also tried some of the varaity donuts witch were nice and warm.We are excited to see them grow to be even better!

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *